A designer shingle roof can give a home the textured appearance of slate or cedar while retaining the familiar format of asphalt shingles. For homeowners comparing roofing options, the decision often comes down to appearance, upfront cost, expected performance, and whether the existing roof needs replacement. In this project, hurricane damage led to a roof replacement, and insurance covered most of the cost, making it possible to choose a higher-end shingle.
Designer Shingle Roof vs. Architectural Shingles
Architectural shingles are a step up from traditional three-tab shingles. They have a dimensional appearance and are commonly chosen as a balance between cost and visual appeal. The estimated price range cited for architectural shingles is about $5.50 to $12.25 per square foot.
Designer shingles typically have a thicker, more detailed appearance and are made to resemble premium roofing materials such as slate or cedar. Their estimated price range is about $12.50 to $15.50 per square foot. These figures are a starting point rather than a project quote; the total cost can depend on the roof, labor, location, and installation requirements.
When comparing estimates, ask contractors to specify what is included, such as removal of the old roof and installation details. Comparing the same scope of work makes it easier to assess the difference in price.
Why Choose a Designer Shingle Roof?
A roof replacement is a chance to consider more than a like-for-like replacement. Designer shingles offer added texture and visual depth, and can create a look inspired by slate or cedar shake without using those materials. This project used CertainTeed Belmont luxury shingles in Colonial Slate, chosen for their classic appearance and variation in tone.
Color and texture can influence how the roof works with the rest of a home’s exterior. Before making a selection, compare samples with the brick, siding, trim, shutters, and other fixed features. If possible, view the sample outdoors in different light, since colors can look different in a showroom or on a screen.
What to Consider Before Installing Designer Shingles
Potential benefits
- Distinctive curb appeal: Their layered profiles can give a roof a more substantial look and echo the appearance of higher-cost materials.
- Weather performance: Designer shingles are often thicker and heavier than basic options. Product performance depends on the specific shingle, correct installation, and local conditions, so check the manufacturer’s specifications for wind ratings and other relevant details.
- Long service life: Depending on the product and installation, expected lifespans can range from 30 to 50 years or more. A lifespan is not a guarantee; review the product warranty and maintenance requirements.
- More style choices: Available profiles and colors can suit a range of home styles.
Potential drawbacks
- Higher initial cost: Designer shingles generally cost more than basic roofing options. Insurance coverage depends on the policy, the reason for replacement, and the claim decision; confirm coverage directly with the insurer before choosing an upgrade.
- Added weight: Their heavier construction may require a check of the roof structure. Ask a qualified roofer to confirm that the home can support the selected product.
- Product and installation differences: Warranties and performance vary. Check the warranty terms and choose an experienced, appropriately qualified contractor who can explain the installation plan.
For a hurricane-prone area, ask how the chosen product is rated for local wind conditions and whether the installation will follow the manufacturer’s requirements. A heavier shingle alone does not guarantee that a roof will withstand severe weather.
Is a Designer Shingle Roof Worth It?
A designer shingle roof may be worth considering if its appearance is important to you, the budget allows for the higher upfront cost, and the roof structure and local requirements are suitable. In this project, the Colonial Slate shingles complemented the home’s limewashed brick, shutters, front door, landscaping, and lawn. The finished roof gave the exterior a more cohesive look and an appearance reminiscent of slate.
However, a premium roof should not be treated as a guaranteed way to increase resale value. A buyer’s response and any effect on a home’s sale price depend on the property and market. Compare the cost with your priorities, how long you expect to stay in the home, and the roof’s condition.
Before deciding, get detailed estimates, verify structural suitability, review warranty terms, and confirm any insurance contribution. A designer shingle roof can be a worthwhile upgrade when its look and specifications meet your needs, but the right choice depends on the home, budget, and installation.
